PRmoment India Awards 2027 PRmoment Leaders

When to speak up: managing Indian brands' reputation in a polarised era

Credit: PRmoment India

It's only human to have different points of view on the incredibly complex issues that make up the state of world affairs today. Making it tougher than ever for brands to have a point if view and create a campaign that runs alongside a flare up in public opinion, often on the same newsfeed.

Patriotic posts, boycotts and pulled campaigns have tested brand reputations this year. Indian brands face more pressure than ever to take a stand. 

PRmoment India spoke to a range of heads of PR firms to understand the challenge of brand reputation in a polarised world. India's PR leaders explain when to speak up, when to stay quiet, and what it costs to get it wrong.

Balance company, community and country

Amit Misra, CEO, MSL South Asia, says, “Brand communications in India today have to balance three things: company, community and country. The real test is whether you can respect all three and still stand for something progressive. That means picking your moments, knowing what you can back up, and being honest about where your business has the right to speak. 

The brands that last are the ones that still find room for a progressive point of view, and back it with action rather than a post. Staying silent isn’t neutral any more, and neither is being noisy. The brands that earn trust are the ones whose actions match their words long after the post has gone out."

In today’s fragmented world, no position is entirely safe

Neha Mehrotra, managing director, Avian We., shares her simple test to decide when a brand should speak up: " Does this affect our business, our people or a commitment we have already made? Have we earned the right to speak through our actions? And will we stand by it when it becomes uncomfortable? If the answer is yes, speak clearly. If the only reason is that everyone else is posting, then pause.

At the same time, we should remember that silence also carries a penalty. “Staying in your lane” cannot become an excuse to avoid responsibility. When your own employees or customers are affected, silence needs a reason too."

 Is “nationalism marketing” now the safest position for a brand, or a new kind of risk?

Mehrotra comments, "In today’s fragmented world, no position is entirely safe. That said, national pride can bring people together. The risk begins when a brand starts deciding who belongs or uses patriotism to question someone else’s loyalty.

For an Indian brand, the strongest expression of national commitment is how it creates jobs, treats people and serves its customers and communities. If you choose to run a patriotic campaign, there must be a clear reason and something substantial behind it. It cannot be an empty slogan or slip into jingoism. Consumers are very aware. They can see through performative patriotism and sycophancy."

Our public is young, online and quick to anger

Tarunjeet Rattan, managing partner, Nucleus PR, says, "A stance is only believed if your behaviour over the previous five years backs it or your next ten years back it up. A position is not a post. It's a promise with a long tail, and your employees, vendors and customers are the ones who have to honour it. India specifically adds another unique layer. Our public is young, online and quick to anger, and a small, loud group can look like a national mood. Before you speak, check whether the noise belongs to your consumers or only to your mentions.

If a cause fails the test, staying in your lane isn't cowardice. It's discipline. Do your job brilliantly and quietly. The brands I trust most rarely announce their values. You can see them in how they treat a complaint, a supplier, an ordinary Tuesday. And by the way, you can choose to have internal town halls and make changes to your policy if you feel strongly about it without it being a public announcement. Your employees, clients and vendors who feel the change are the ones who will become your biggest champions and create a reputation for you that might just outlast you."

Rattan also warns against the easy patriotism as brand promotion policy, saying, "Once you've claimed patriotism as a brand value, every delayed salary, quality lapse and late vendor payment reads as hypocrisy, and the public will point it out faster than any competitor. That’s a reputation disaster waiting to happen. Add to this, brands don't only sell to the nation. They employ people of every community, export to markets that watch our politics, and serve an increasingly sceptical audience that is wary of anything that feels like borrowed sentiment. The safest position isn't louder patriotism. It's competence."

Nationalism is a safe marketing bet, but remain autehntic

Pranav Kumar, founder and CEO of Alkimyx, said, " Brands in India must be incredibly nuanced about when they take public positions. India’s cultural pluralities and sensitivities are beyond unique; they are diverse, making taking on a vocal or woke issue a bit of a tightrope for sure. Living in polarising times does not make it any easier as well. For a brand to take on a public position requires foresight and courage. Staying clear of active positions on politics, religious, communal sentiments, or prevailing anti-incumbency undertones is not, obviously, a good idea.

Today, brands need to lead with clarity, authenticity, and be always aligned to their core values. That is a good starting point. Taking positions that resonate within your brand values or organisational DNA is always seen as authentic by audiences. By that logic, brands should take public positions on a range of moments, from national pride and just causes promoting communal harmony, as well as anything that is seen as stemming from misinformation and disinformation. At an age when brands must contend with hate, better to be safe than sorry!

Commenting on nationalism as a safe marketing position, Kumar opines, "Is it a ‘marketing safe haven’ for sure.  But I must submit that a few brands have pushed that a bit too far and a bit too deep in the moment. That comes across as opportunistic, commerce-led, and less conviction, for sure. I do not see nationalism marketing as a risk overall, but only if a brand is a bit too over the top with it. That’s inauthentic, and audiences can sniff that out."

He adds, "Standing by the country at a pivotal time like war is patriotic and hence the right conviction. While brands can be altruistic, everything at the end of the day is tied to commerce as well. So, it’s not all of that entirely (just being altruistic). But sending the right messages is. Doing the right thing gets you the right perception and helps you be seen as favourable and authentic."

In a polarised climate, disagreement is certain

Dr. Sarvesh Tiwari, founder & MD, PRP Group Pvt Ltd says, " Reputation management can no longer sit only with media relations, advertising or crisis teams. It has to work as a management function that informs business decisions, corporate conduct and the way a company engages its stakeholders. In a polarised climate, disagreement is certain. Becoming controversy-proof is unrealistic, so the sensible goal is to build enough trust and goodwill that a company can absorb criticism without losing its identity. The strongest brand is the one whose credibility is solid enough to survive criticism."

Withdrawing an ad in these challenging times.

Tiwari explains, "The danger lies in what a quick retreat tells the market. A brand that backs off at the first sign of opposition signals that its convictions can be negotiated. Digging in only to prove courage can be just as careless. The useful question is whether the brand misread a cultural sensitivity or is facing opposition while acting consistently with values it has held for years. The first calls for correction and an honest explanation. The second calls for steady nerves.

Most of the real failure happens well before the release date. Companies spend heavily on creative work and consumer insight, yet reputational risk review often gets a few hurried hours. India is not one market. A message that feels warm and progressive in one city can land very differently in another. An ad can be taken down overnight, but the memory of the controversy can linger for years. Reputation work has to begin at the drawing board."

Reputation is not protected by avoiding every difficult conversation

Girish Balachandran, Group CEO of The PRactice Group and founder of ON PURPOSE. agrees with Tiwari, saying, " There is a difference between recognising that a creative execution has been misjudged and withdrawing it simply because a vocal section of the internet is unhappy. In the first instance, reconsidering the work can be a responsible decision. In the second, a quick retreat can create the impression that the brand has no conviction in its own thinking.

The larger risk is the precedent it sets. If brands repeatedly withdraw work at the first sign of controversy, they may become increasingly cautious about representing the diversity and complexity of the society they operate in. Reputation is not protected by avoiding every difficult conversation. It is built through consistency, judgement and the ability to explain decisions clearly, even when those decisions are unpopular.

Ultimately, brands should be careful about confusing the visibility of a position with the credibility of the values behind it."

Follow us on WhatsApp

If you enjoyed this article, you can subscribe for free to our weekly event and subscriber alerts.

We have four email alerts in total - covering ESG, PR news, events and awards. Enter your email address below to find out more: